KEEPING A LID ON BUDGET EXPECTATIONS
Two days before it was elected on May 21 election, Labor released the costings of its election commitments.
Amid the frantic final days of the campaign, Labor’s Better Budget, Better Economy statement received only a passing inspection by media and economic commentators.
At the core of the Labor costings was a raft of promises including cleaner and cheaper energy, fee-free TAFE and cheaper child care, as well as a crackdown on government waste.
Labor’s Budget strategy was costed to have a net aggregate impact of $7.4 billion over the four-year forward estimates period, starting from the pre-election forecast of a near $78 billion budget deficit in 2022-23.
But days after Labor’s poll victory, new Treasurer Dr Jim Chalmers was quickly lowering expectations of a big-spending budget delivered by the new government.
His Treasury Secretary Dr Steven Kennedy also sounded the alarm in early June, warning that the Government would need to identify structural savings in the budget or raise additional tax revenues to “rebuild fiscal buffers.”
Significantly, the Treasury head cited spending pressures in the areas of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS), aged care, defence, health and infrastructure.
Releasing the Labor costings on May 19, Dr Chalmers and now Finance Minister Senator Katy Gallagher provided a detailed list of where money would be spent on new initiatives and savings delivered over the four-year forward estimates period.
The two big ticket items were the Cheaper Child Care policy, costing $5 billion over four years, and the Fixing the Aged Care Crisis policy, costed at almost $2.5 billion.
The Fee-Free TAFE policy was estimated to cost almost $800 over four years, while cutting the Pharmaceutical Benefit Scheme co-payment to $30 would cost $765 million and changes to Medicare, $750 million.
Labor’s policy for an Electric Car Discount was costed at $388 million over four years.
Externally, Labor flagged additional development assistance to the Pacific, at a cost of $538 million, plus $481 million targeted at deepening Australia’s engagement with South-East Asia.
To help pay for its election promises, the now-Treasurer and Finance Minister identified a range of savings across infrastructure projects, principally the abolition of the Regionalisation Fund, saving $400 million.
But most of Labor’s proposed savings were sourced from measures within Treasury and the Public Service.
For example, Labor promised to extend and boost existing Australian Taxation Office program, reaping more than $3 billion over four years, complemented by additional $1.9 billion of revenue through a higher taxation take on multinational companies.
In addition, the new government planned to find $3 billion over four years through savings from external labour, offset by $475 million through “reinvestment” in the Australian Public Service.
The Federal Treasurer will have an opportunity to confirm the Government’s spending and savings plans when he delivers a statement to the new Federal Parliament late in July.
Ahead of his first Budget on October 25, Dr Chalmers will also advise the National Cabinet on the pressures facing the budgets of Federal, State and Territory governments.
His report will identify anticipated fiscal pressures, with a focus on areas of joint funding responsibility – spelling a warning for future Federal government support for state and territory programs.
Meanwhile, as the Treasurer and his Treasury Secretary sharpen their pencils and run their ruler over current spending, they received in mid-June a glimmer of hope for a smaller budget deficit.
Latest Department of Finance monthly figures showed that to the end of May, the progressive budget deficit was $27 billion lower than Treasury expectations for the same period.
That would translate to a full-year deficit substantially below the near-$78 billion deficit projected in the pre-election update.
Positive news certainly, but the Treasurer will want to ensure that expectations are managed appropriately ahead of some tough Budget medicine in late October.
Gavin Clancy is a Senior Consultant at Lunik